What do finance brokers do?
Consumers may believe a finance broker is uniquely positioned to obtain a better deal than the consumer could obtain personally, particularly in the context of home loans. However, consumers must be mindful that many brokers will only deal with a panel of lenders who have agreed to pay the broker a commission. Brokers will often only arrange loans with a limited number of lenders, and will not consider all the loans available. There is a risk that a broker acting under these arrangements will arrange a loan that is most advantageous for the broker, rather than a loan that is in the best interests of the consumer. Some brokers also charge large up-front fees to arrange a loan. Consumers need to factor these risks and costs into their decisions and shop around for the best deal.
The NCCP Act includes finance broking within its definition of “credit assistance” (s 8 NCCP Act). Like all persons providing credit assistance, finance brokers are required to hold an Australian Credit Licence, a condition of which is that the licensee must be a member of an ASIC-approved dispute resolution scheme (see “Solving disputes with creditors” in Unauthorised transactions and ePayments Code).
Under section 180A of the NCCP Act, courts have the power to make orders remedying unfair or dishonest conduct by a credit service provider (including a finance broker) where the assistance was provided on or after 1 March 2013. Subsections 180A(3) and (4) set out a broad list of relevant considerations that the court may take into account in determining whether to make such an order, including whether or not the applicant is a member of a disadvantaged class of people (s 180A(4)(b)).
Otherwise, the ASIC Act sets out general prohibitions (similar to those in the Australian Consumer Law) against unfair practices such as false representations, misleading or deceptive conduct (ss 12DA–DC, 12DF) and unconscionable conduct (ss 12CA–12CC) in relation to the provision of financial services. The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) also contains relevant prohibitions in sections 1041E–H, including prohibition against “dishonest conduct” in the provision of financial goods and services (s 1041G). Under section 1041I, a person who suffers loss as a result of contraventions of sections 1041E–H has a cause of action under that provision to recover that loss from the contravener.
Until 2 October 2011, licensees were exempted from providing a credit guide, quote and credit proposal, provided certain conditions were met (reg 28L NCCP Regulations). Since 2 October 2011, before providing credit assistance, finance brokers have to give consumers a credit guide that discloses (s 113 NCCP Act):
• the broker’s name and contact details;
• the broker’s Australian Credit Licence number;
• any fees, charges and commissions payable and the manner of their calculation;
• the names of the six credit providers with whom the broker conducts the most business;
• a broker’s obligation to give a consumer a copy of a preliminary assessment of whether or not the credit sought is unsuitable for the consumer;
• a broker’s obligation not to suggest entering, or assist a consumer to enter, or increase the credit limit under, an unsuitable credit contract;
• the broker’s internal dispute resolution procedure;
• the details of the dispute resolution scheme of which the broker is a member.
A broker also has to provide a customer with a detailed, personalised quote before recommending entry into any loan, disclosing the maximum amount of fees payable, a breakdown of those fees and whether or not the fees are payable if a credit contract is not ultimately entered into (s 114 NCCP Act).
Under section 121 of the NCCP Act, a finance broker must provide a credit proposal to a consumer when they suggest that:
• the consumer apply, or they assist the consumer to apply, for a particular credit contract;
• the consumer apply, or they assist the consumer to apply, for an increase to the credit limit of a particular credit contract; or
• the consumer remain in a particular credit contract.
The credit proposal must disclose:
• all fees and charges paid to the broker and the method of their calculation;
• a reasonable estimate of all commissions paid to the broker in relation to the credit contract;
• a reasonable estimate of all fees likely to be paid by the consumer to the credit provider; and
• the amount of credit available to the consumer after such amounts are paid out of the loan.
Since 1 July 2010, finance brokers, and others providing credit assistance, have been obliged to make reasonable inquiries into a consumer’s financial situation, requirements and objectives before suggesting that a consumer enters into a particular loan or increases a credit limit on a particular loan. Brokers bear the corresponding duty to make a preliminary assessment using this information in relation to the suitability of any loan before recommending it, and are prohibited from suggesting that a consumer enter into a loan, or increase a credit limit on a particular loan, if the contract is unsuitable for the consumer (ss 115–120, 123 NCCP Act).
The criteria for assessing suitability of a loan are generally the same as those discussed above regarding the responsible lending obligations of credit providers (see “Responsible lending obligations: suitability” in Understanding credit and finance).
A finance broker’s failure to acquit its obligations under the NCCP Act gives an affected consumer a right to apply to a court or external dispute resolution scheme for a compensation order under section 178, or another order compensating for loss or damage under section 179.
Part 4A of the Consumer Credit (Victoria) Act 1995 (Vic) (“CCV Act”) regulated the activities of finance brokers after 1 July 1999, but only applied when a fee was charged directly to the consumer by a broker. Part 4A continued to apply to broking activities in Victoria until 1 January 2011. Among other things, the CCV Act limited the circumstances in which a broker was entitled to charge fees.
In the past some brokers included a clause in their documents of appointment that gave them the right to place a caveat over the consumer’s property, which prevented the consumer from disposing of that property until the broker had been paid. Since 1 January 2011, this practice (including the threat to lodge a caveat) has been prohibited under section 114(6) of the NCCP Act.