As described under "Dispute the fine: take the matter to court" above, there are several reasons why you might choose, or be obliged, to appear in the Magistrates' Court. The procedure may vary according to the purpose of the hearing.
As discussed under "Apply for review by the enforcement agency", above, you can request an internal review of the agency's decision to issue you with a fine. This can only be done before the fine is lodged with the Infringements Court. If the application for withdrawal is made on the basis of "special circumstances", the agency may either withdraw the infringement notice or decline to withdraw the notice and refer the matter to the Magistrates' Court for hearing.
The same process applies as for cases referred under section 66 of the Infringements Act after an application for revocation has been made other than on the ground of special circumstances (see below).
Section 66 of the Infringements Act provides that a matter may be revoked and referred or sent to the Magistrates' Court for their consideration where there are sufficient grounds or good reasons for a revocation. Where a case is referred to the Magistrates' Court under section 66, other than where it is an application for revocation on the basis of special circumstances, you (the defendant) or your lawyer will receive a Notice of Hearing. This notice will set out a "mention date".
- If you plead guilty, the matter will be heard and determined on that mention date.
- If you plead not guilty, the matter will generally be adjourned and set down for a contest hearing at a later date.
Each matter will generally be referred to the court nearest to where the offence is alleged to have occurred. If you have multiple matters, this means that they may be referred to different courts. If you wish to have all the matters dealt with at once, in the same court, you will need to identify all the separate matters, so that you can then try to persuade the agencies involved to agree to attend a single hearing. You can also ask the Magistrates' Court to list the cases at the same court, for a single hearing.
For more information on court procedures, see: "Appearing in the Magistrates' Court", below. See also: Chapters 2*1 Self-representation, and 3*5 Sentencing in the Magistrates' Court.
Where a case is referred to court under section 66 on the basis of "special circumstances", your matter or matters will be listed together at Melbourne Magistrates' Court for first mention on the Special Circumstances List. If you plead guilty at that mention, the Magistrate can then deal with the matter at that time.
The Special Circumstances List (a forum just for special circumstances applications that sits on the Thursdays at the Melbourne Magistrates Court) aims to identify and address the issues underlying the "offending behaviours" of persons with special circumstances. Most often, defendants in this list will have their matters dismissed, or adjourned on an undertaking of good behaviour for a specified period, after which the matters will be dismissed.
For more information on court procedures, see: "Appearing in the Magistrates' Court", below. See also: Chapters 2*1 Self-representation, and 3*5 Sentencing in the Magistrates' Court.
Where the Infringements Registrar decides not to revoke the order, you may apply to have the application for revocation referred to the Magistrates' Court, as discussed under "Challenging decision not to revoke", above. The application is, in effect, an appeal from the decision of the registrar to refuse the revocation application. As discussed above, the magistrate will allow the appeal and revoke the enforcement order if satisfied that non-payment could result in imprisonment (i.e. if the defendant has no assets and inadequate income to pay the fines) or if justice otherwise requires that the case be dealt with on its merits.
The application may also proceed by way of consent. If the enforcement order is revoked and the defendant pleads guilty to the alleged offence, the Magistrate will immediately proceed to hear and determine the matter.
You do not have to wait until the fine is registered with the Infringements Court to get the matter heard in court. As discussed under "Dispute the fine: take the matter to court", above, you can elect for the fine to be referred directly to the Magistrates' Court when it is still at the infringement notice or penalty reminder notice stage.
Once the matter has been listed you will receive a Notice of Hearing. This notice will set out a mention date. If you plead guilty, the matter will be heard and determined on that date. If you are pleading not guilty, the matter may be heard on that day or adjourned to a later date.
If you decline to be dealt with under the infringements system (i.e. you opt to have the matter dealt with in the Magistrates' Court at the infringement notice or penalty reminder notice stage) and you may have "special circumstances", your lawyer should contact the Enforcement Review Coordinator at the Magistrates' Court. Upon proof of "special circumstances", the Enforcement Review Coordinator may arrange for the matter to be adjourned to the Special Circumstances List. This will be done administratively (i.e. there is no need for you or your lawyer to appear in court for the adjournment).
You (and your lawyer, if you have one) should arrive in court at least 15 minutes before the hearing time. You might want to meet your lawyer earlier to discuss what will happen and what you might be asked in court. You or your lawyer will need to announce your "appearance" in person with the associate in the court where the matter is listed to be heard. This simply means approaching the Magistrate's associate before the Magistrate has entered the court and telling the associate your name so that the Magistrate will then know you are there ready for your matter to be heard.
It is important for you to be present at the hearing even if you do have a lawyer to appear. This is generally your only opportunity to argue your case before a Magistrate. If you do not appear, the court is more likely to rule against you. Also, some sentencing dispositions (such as an adjournment on an undertaking of good behaviour) require that you consent to the order. If you are applying on the grounds of "special circumstances", it is also helpful if a case worker or social worker is present at the hearing, as this sends a strong message to the court that you are being supported and that your difficulties are being addressed.
When the associate calls your matter, you or your lawyer will proceed to the bar table and, if you have a lawyer, they will announce that they are appearing for you. The Magistrate will then ask the enforcement agency prosecutor for an outline of the alleged offences, and will then ask whether you plead guilty or not guilty. If you plead not guilty, the matter will be adjourned to a contest date for further hearing. If you plead guilty, the Magistrate will ask for sentencing submissions. This gives you or your lawyer the opportunity to explain your circumstances and suggest a lesser penalty than the Magistrate might otherwise consider.
For more information about the Magistrates' Court, see: Chapter 2*1 Self-representation.
Sentencing options in the Magistrates' Court range from imprisonment to unconditional dismissal; for a fuller discussion of these options, see: Chapter 3*5 Sentencing in the Magistrates' Court.
The Magistrates' Court has the power to impose a fine that is smaller or larger than the penalty set out in the legislation that creates the offence. If there are several offences involved, the Magistrate may be able to impose a single penalty covering all the offences. The court can also grant an order allowing you to pay the fine by instalments or giving you extra time to pay.
For people with "special circumstances", an unconditional dismissal or an adjournment without conviction on conditions often will be the most appropriate sentencing disposition. For example, the power to adjourn without conviction on conditions was used by the Magistrates' Court in the case of an elderly homeless man with over $100,000 worth of fines. The court ordered the defendant to comply with a case management plan prepared by his case worker to address the underlying causes of his offending behaviours.
The court may adjourn the matter for up to 60 months, and can impose conditions for you to meet during this period. These can include, for example, completing a driver education course, or undertaking drug or alcohol treatment. After the adjournment, if you have met the conditions set, the court may decide to waive any further penalty without any need for you to appear. However, if you have not complied with the conditions set by the court, another sentence may be imposed.
If you receive a fine as a sentencing disposition imposed by the Magistrates' Court, you may be able to apply for an instalment order or extension of time in which to pay (see: "Negotiate a payment plan: extra time or instalments", above). You may also be able to apply for a CBO, which will allow you to do community work instead of paying the fine (see: "Do community work", above). If you do not pay within a month after the time specified, or breach the conditions of the CBO, the court may order you to be arrested and sentence you to a period in prison (see: "Arrests and imprisonment", above). You may also receive a combination of prison sentence and CBO.
GOING TO COURT :: Last updated: Thu Jul 1st 2010


Prev
Next
Printable Version