Although protesting is a right, protesters may be charged with obstruction, trespass, unlawful assembly, offensive behaviour, besetting, assault, resist or hinder police, riot or affray. Property-related offences include property damage as well as burglary. A range of criminal offences can apply to forestry protests.
The police may threaten to charge a person with obstruction if they simply want someone out of the way.
However, to charge a person with obstruction under Victorian law, the police must prove that the person was in some way preventing “the free passage of the public” (s 4(e) SOA). The maximum penalty for obstruction under state law is 5 pu.
Commonwealth law has a section more clearly aimed at demonstrations: a person “taking part in an assembly [who] engages in unreasonable obstruction” at a Commonwealth facility or in a Commonwealth territory commits an offence (s 9 Public Order (Protection of Persons and Property) Act 1971 (Cth) (“Public Order Act”). The penalty is a fine of up to 20 pu.
Under Victorian law it is an offence to wilfully trespass in any place and neglect or refuse to leave that place after being warned to do so by the owner, occupier or a person authorised by the owner or occupier (s 9(1)(d) SOA). The maximum penalty is 25 pu or six months jail.
The corresponding Commonwealth offences do not require that a warning be given; but federal law does provide the defences of “lawful” or “reasonable excuse” (s 89(1) Crimes Act (Cth); ss 11(1), 12(1) Public Order Act (Cth)). The penalty for both offences is a fine of up to 10 pu.
Trespass on certain types of premises is governed by different Acts. For example, regulation 35 of the Defence Regulations 1952 (Cth) authorises the federal Minister for Defence to declare a place to be a prohibited area. These Regulations also create offences of entering or remaining in a prohibited area without permission; the maximum penalty for these offences is 20 pu or imprisonment for six months, or both.
In Victoria there is a common law offence of unlawful assembly. This prohibits an assembly of three or more people with an intent to commit a crime by open force, or with intent to carry out any common purpose, whether lawful or not, in such a manner as to give reasonable people in the vicinity reasonable grounds to fear a breach of the peace.
Also, under section 10 of the Unlawful Assemblies and Processions Act 1958 (Vic), any person who attends and takes part in an unlawful assembly, which includes any political demonstration, is guilty of an offence. This charge is very rarely used, but it does illustrate the power that governments have to stop “political” actions if they wish to do so.
Under Victorian law it is an offence to use indecent or threatening language or behaviour in or near a public place, or within the view or hearing of a person in a public place (s 17(1) SOA). The maximum penalty for a first offence is 10 pu or two months jail. “Public place” is very widely defined and includes roads, streets, alleys, footpaths, parks, gardens, railway stations, trains, piers, churches, state schools, theatres, markets, sporting grounds and open areas. It can be argued that current community standards dictate that the conduct over which a person has been charged may not amount to obscene, indecent or threatening behaviour.
The Commonwealth “offensive or disorderly manner” law is associated with the trespass law. Under sections 11(2) and 12(2)(a) of the Public Order Act, it is an offence for a person who “while trespassing on premises in a territory” or “being in or on Commonwealth premises … behaves in an offensive or disorderly manner”. Both these offences carry penalties of up to 20 pu.
Note that the meaning of “offensive or disorderly” has to be established, and that the common law defence of “reasonable excuse” can be used.
Under Victorian law it is an offence for anyone (alone or with others) to wilfully and without lawful authority “beset” any premises, whether public or private, for the purpose and with the effect of obstructing, hindering or impeding by an assembly of people any person’s lawful right to enter, use or leave such premises (s 52(1A) SOA). The maximum penalty is 15 pu or three months jail.
The charge of besetting requires all entrances to the property to be obstructed, and that there was no other option for entering the premises (i.e. the premises must have been completely surrounded).
Under Victorian law it is an offence to “assault, resist, obstruct hinder or delay” an emergency worker on duty (s 51 SOA). “Emergency worker” includes police officers, protective services officers, ambulance officers, and firemen. It is also an offence to assault, resist, obstruct, hinder or delay a council worker on duty. The prohibition extends to assaults on registered health practitioners (s 51A SOA).
Under the previous law that prohibited resisting arrest and hindering arrest, “resisting” meant opposing by force; “hindering” meant making the arrest or other police action more difficult to carry out. It did not matter whether the resistance or hindrance actually prevented the arrest or other action. It was not an offence to passively resist arrest, or to run away before an arrest had commenced. It was also not an offence to resist or hinder a police officer who was not properly executing their duty (e.g. the officer is making an illegal arrest, or is using excessive force).
Presently, we are not sure how the new law will be applied but it seems that almost any behaviour might support a charge of “delaying” an emergency worker. The maximum penalty is six months jail or a fine of 60 pu.
An assault with violence against an emergency worker worker is a very serious offence and now attracts a minimum mandatory imprisonment sentence under section 10AA of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic).
It is also an offence under Victorian law for someone to obstruct, assault, threaten or abuse an authorised officer in the performance of their functions under the National Parks Act 1975 (Vic) (s 45(1)). The maximum penalty is six months jail or 20 pu.
Under Commonwealth law it is an offence to “intentionally and knowingly obstruct, resist, hinder, use violence against, threaten or intimidate” a member of the Federal Police carrying out a “function or duty” (sch 1 item 149(1) Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth)). The maximum penalty is two years jail.
Riot is a common law offence. The prosecution must prove that three or more people were gathered with a common purpose, and they used or threated force or violence against anyone who opposed them, in a way that would terrify reasonable people. The Magistrates’ Court does not have jurisdiction to hear riot charges; these offences are heard in the County Court. The maximum penalty is 10 years imprisonment.
Affray is a common law offence. The prosecution must prove that violence (i.e. an unlawful display of force) was used by one or more people against another person or people, and this might cause a reasonable bystander to be terrified. Charges of affray can be heard in a Magistrates’ Court. The maximum penalty is five years imprisonment.
Damage to property could occur unintentionally during a protest or it may be an actual part of a political protest.
Under Victorian law there are a number of offences that relate to damaging property. The most significant of these is set out in section 197 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) (“Crimes Act (Vic)”), which provides for jail sentences of up to 15 years where there is an intention to endanger life or damage property. Where the intention is to simply damage property, the maximum penalty is 10 years imprisonment. Generally this section is used for the more serious examples of damage to property. This charge could be laid by police in situations involving gluing padlocks, painting security cameras or pulling down a fence. In addition to the sentence, police will usually ask the court to order that the defendant pay the cost of repairing the damaged property; this can be a significant amount.
Wilful damage charges are generally used for circumstances where there has been less significant damage to property (i.e. under $5000 to repair). These less serious property damage offences can be found in sections 7 and 9 of the SOA. The maximum penalties are much lower: six months jail or a 25 pu.
Penalties for property damage offences can range from an “adjourned undertaking” through to imprisonment. If you cause only minor damage to property, and you have few or no police priors, the penalty will fall towards the lower end of this range.
Penalties and compensation orders will reflect the damage alleged to have occurred. The prosecution should provide some evidence by way of statements or quotes as to the cost of repair should they seek a restitution order.
Recently we have seen the introduction of safe access zones to ensure privacy and safe access to premises at which abortions are provided (s 11A Public Health and Wellbeing Act 2008 (Vic)). Breach of the prohibition on preventing safe access is an offence carrying a maximum penalty of 120 pu or 12 months imprisonment. Prohibited behaviour includes “communicating by any means in relation to abortions in a manner that is able to be seen or heard by a person accessing, seeking to access or leaving a premises at which abortions are provided and is reasonably likely to cause distress and anxiety”.
In Victoria it is an offence to mark publicly visible graffiti without first receiving the consent of the property owner (s 5 Graffiti Prevention Act 2007 (Vic) (“GPA”)). It is also an offence to mark publicly visible graffiti that is offensive, even with consent (s 6 GPA); however, section 6 provides an exception for reasonable political comment. The maximum penalty for breaching sections 5 or 6 of the GPA is two years jail.
Under the GPA (s 7), it is also an offence to possess a graffiti implement with the intention of using it to breach sections 5 or 6. The maximum penalty for possession of a graffiti implement is 25 pu.
It is an offence to deposit advertising material anywhere but in a mailbox (s 45L EPA), including on a vehicle (s 45N). It is not an offence to deposit material that has a “political purpose” into mailboxes labelled with “no junk mail” or “no advertising material” (s 45 M(1)(b)).
There are other laws, including local council laws, relevant to damage to property, graffiti and postering. It is an offence to post placards, bills, stickers or other documents, or to write, paint on or deface virtually any structure, including such things as trees and gates, without the consent of the owner (s 45(O) Environment Protection Act 1970 (Vic) (“EPA”); s 10 SOA). It is up to the defendant to prove that they had the owner’s consent. The maximum penalty under the SOA is 15 pu or three months imprisonment, although a fine of below $500 is more likely. Under the EPA, the maximum penalty is 10 pu. In addition to a fine, the defendant can be ordered to pay clean-up costs.
Burglary is the offence of trespassing on property with criminal intent. This could apply to protestors who enter private property with the deliberate intention of damaging it. The penalty is up to 10 years imprisonment.
There are a number of different charges of assault, each with a different penalty range, depending on how the assault occurred, whether a weapon was used, and what injuries were caused.
In addition to the offences outlined above (under “Common charges associated with protests”), there are a range of criminal offences that can be used against people protesting in forests. Legislation, including the Safety on Public Land Act 2004 (Vic) (“SPL Act”) and the Sustainable Forests (Timber) Act 2004 (Vic) (“SFT Act”), contribute an array of offences, virtually identical in character to existing offences under the Conservation, Forests and Lands Act 1987 (Vic), the Forests Act 1958 (Vic) and the Land Act 1958 (Vic).
The SPL Act empowers the Secretary of the Victorian Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning (DELWP) to make declarations that certain areas are public safety zones and to exclude the public from those areas of state forest. Declared areas can include public recreational areas. Offences under the SPL Act tend to relate to breaches of these zones and attract fines up to 20 pu (ss 10, 14, 15, 16). One of the exceptions to this is the offence of hindering or obstructing an officer of the DELWP while exercising their duties or powers under this Act, which attracts a maximum fine of 60 pu (s 20).
The SFT Act includes offences of:
•failing to give your name and address to a DELWP officer (s 84; maximum penalty: 5 pu);
•hindering or obstructing a DELWP officer exercising their duties or powers under the SFT Act (s 86; maximum penalty: 60 pu); and
•threatening or abusing a DELWP officer in the execution of their duty (s 87; penalty: 60 pu).
For more information about offences relating to forest operations, contact Lawyers for Forests.
Lawyers for Forests
PO Box 550, Collins Street West Vic 8007
Tel: 9600 4224