Protesting: your rights and the police

 

Our rights to protest, demonstrate and take part in political activities are recognised by the United Nations’ Universal Declaration of Human Rights 1948 (UDHR) as well as by many other international human rights conventions and covenants.

A right to freedom of peaceful assembly is part of international law under the UDHR (Article 20) and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights 1966 (ICCPR) (Article 21). The right to engage in participatory democracy “without unreasonable restrictions” is clearly acknowledged by the ICCPR (Article 25).

Although it is difficult to assert these rights in Australia because most of the rights have not been incorporated into Australian domestic law, you do have legal rights when protesting.

Police

Protesting is confrontational and often attracts the police’s attention. Sometimes the police accommodate a protest and don’t exercise their authority. You may consider contacting the police before a protest, to allay their concerns about the protest’s intentions. However, the police often do exercise their authority by (sometimes pre-emptively) arresting and detaining people suspected of committing offences.

If engaging in a protest that you anticipate may result in arrest or detention, it is good to understand the nature and scope of police powers, and the common charges laid against protesters.

While an overview of the law of bail and police powers can be found in Arrest, search, interrogation and your rights, and How bail works, respectively, some of the key bail issues and common charges associated with protests are outlined below.

Move-on powers

The Summary Offences Act 1966 (Vic) (“SOA”) (s 6(1)) authorises police and Protective Services Officers (PSOs) to direct a person to leave a public place, if the police officer or PSO believes on reasonable grounds that:

a the person is breaching the peace, or is likely to do so; or

b the person is endangering the safety of another person, or is likely to do so; or

c the person’s behaviour is likely to cause injury or property damage, or is a risk to public safety.

A direction to “move-on” can be given to an individual or to a group of people, and may require the person or group to avoid that particular public place for 24 hours. It is an offence to contravene a direction (penalty: 5 penalty units).

Under the SOA (s 6(5)), people cannot be directed to move-on if they are:

picketing a place of employment; or

demonstrating; or

holding banners or signs or speaking in public.

It is important to note that what is required is that the police officer or PSO has reasonable grounds to believe that certain things are “likely to happen”. They do not have to state the basis for their belief.

Bail issues

If the police are going to charge you immediately with an offence, they may seek to impose bail conditions that cover the period up until your case is heard in court. Imposing a geographical exclusion zone (being a place or area you must not visit or may only visit at specified times) is a common bail condition used against demonstrators to prevent them from returning to the protest site.

The object of bail should be to ensure that you attend court, and not to control your life. If you cannot negotiate with police to not include an oppressive bail condition, you have four options:

1 accept bail and comply with the condition;

2 accept bail and breach the condition – here, you risk bail being refused if you are re-arrested;

3 accept bail and seek to have the condition changed at a later date by a court; or

4 refuse bail and stay in custody until you can have the condition removed by a court (during business hours) or by a bail justice (out of hours).

If you are putting your case before a magistrate, consider whether you have a legitimate reason for attending a designated area (e.g. attending work, study or transport connections), which would make the imposition of a geographical exclusion zone overly oppressive. Such arguments have been successfully made in the Magistrates’ Court to challenge these types of bail conditions. If, however, a magistrate decides that the bail condition should stand, and you are forced to accept the condition or lose your freedom, as a last resort you can consider lodging an urgent application to the Supreme Court to delete the condition. For further information, see How bail works.

Fines

If a court imposes a fine as a penalty, it must take into account your personal circumstances and capacity to pay a fine. You may request to pay a fine by instalments, or to work off any fines through community work.


NOTE

1 Under Victorian law, for the financial year (1 July 2015 to 30 June 2016), the value of 1 penalty unit (pu) is $151.67.

2 Under Commonwealth law, the value of one (1) pu is $170.

For more information about penalty units, seeA note about penalty units”.